Back To Resources

5 Sustainable Ecommerce Customer Retention Strategies For The Biggest Impact

Acquiring new customers takes way more resources than keeping your existing customers. Prioritizing customer retention is one of the most cost-effective ways to grow your business.

So how do you do it?

By getting the basics right and then giving your customers what they want: a more sustainable shopping experience.

In this guide, we’ll explore effective ecommerce customer retention strategies that can transform the way you engage and retain customers. From implementing robust loyalty programs to integrating cutting-edge sustainability solutions like EcoCart’s carbon offsetting, we’ll cover key tactics that not only foster loyalty but also enhance your brand’s appeal.

What Is Customer Retention?

Customer retention refers to the strategies and actions businesses employ to keep their existing customers engaged and loyal over time. It involves encouraging repeat business and fostering a positive, ongoing relationship with customers through effective communication, superior service, and by delivering consistent value. Effective customer retention is crucial as it helps businesses stabilize their revenue, reduce marketing costs, and build a reliable customer base.

How to calculate your customer retention rate

Calculating the retention rate is straightforward and provides crucial insight into customer loyalty. To determine this metric, choose a specific time period, count the number of customers at the start, and then count how many of those same customers you still have at the end of the period. Exclude any new customers acquired during this time. The formula is:

Customer Retention Rate = (Number of Customers at End of Period/Number of Customers at Start of Period) × 100%

This calculation gives you the percentage of customers who continue to do business with you, helping you gauge the effectiveness of your retention strategies.

Why Is Customer Retention Important In Ecommerce?

Retaining customers is often more cost-effective than acquiring new ones. How cost effective? Increasing customer retention rates by just 5% can boost profits by a noticeable 25% to 95% . This happens because of two compounding reasons:

  1. Repeat customers tend to spend more over time, with data showing that they spend more with the brand as time goes on.
  2. Loyal customers also amplify brand visibility through word-of-mouth and social sharing, effectively reducing marketing and advertising costs.

By focusing on customer retention, ecommerce businesses can enhance their return on investment, establish a stable revenue stream, and foster a dedicated customer base that contributes to long-term business resilience and success.

How Sustainability Boosts Customer Retention

As consumer awareness and demand for sustainable products continue to rise, sustainability has emerged as an important factor in customer retention. The shifting consumer preferences are especially pronounced among younger generations like Millennials and Gen Z, who significantly prioritize environmental impact in their purchasing decisions. For instance, a substantial 75% of Gen Z shoppers are more focused on how a business practices sustainability than the brand name.

It’s not just Millennials and Gen Z, either. Nearly 80% of all consumers modify their shopping habits based on a brand’s social responsibility and environmental impact, with 77% more likely to spend with companies that maintain a strong corporate social responsibility pledge.

This trend is further supported by statistics showing that 87% of consumers will purchase from a company advocating for issues they care about, and 73% of global consumers would change their consumption habits to reduce environmental impact.

Implementing sustainable practices not only meets these consumer expectations but also enhances an already powerful customer retention strategy.

Download our FREE ebook:

Want more juicy statistics about sustainability in ecommerce? Download our State Of Sustainability In Ecommerce Report to see what the data from our survey of 10K global consumers reveals.

How To Increase Customer Retention In Ecommerce

Increasing customer retention in ecommerce hinges on several core elements that enhance the customer experience and encourage repeat business. If you don’t already have these things in order, then begin here:

  1. Provide Exceptional Customer Service: Providing prompt, helpful, and empathetic customer service is the most important thing to get in order when trying to improve customer retention. Excellent customer service involves delivering prompt, helpful, and empathetic support across multiple channels, including email, live chat, and social media. A responsive support team is key to building strong customer relationships. They efficiently handle inquiries and quickly resolve any customer complaints or issues, keeping your customers happy and connected before any problems can escalate.
  2. Facilitate A Smooth Purchase and Return Processes: Ensure that the buying process is as seamless as possible. This includes an intuitive website interface, straightforward navigation, and a hassle-free checkout experience. Equally important is a clear and fair return policy that builds trust and reduces purchase hesitations.
  3. Provide High-Quality Products: Offering products that meet or exceed customer expectations is fundamental. This includes ensuring product quality, providing accurate product descriptions, and consistently reviewing and adapting your offerings based on customer feedback.
  4. Encourage Customer Engagement and Feedback: Regularly collect customer feedback and encourage customers to to enhance the customer experience. Encouraging customers to share their insights helps drive higher customer satisfaction by not only showing your customers that you value their opinions but also allowing you to refine your services and offerings continually. Customer surveys, online feedback forms, and social media polls allow you to get input from a wide and varied audience.
  5. Implement Sustainable Business Practices: The majority of consumers actively seek sustainable brands and products, making sustainability an obvious direction for most ecommerce businesses. How obvious? Seventy-seven percent of consumer products and retail organizations found that sustainability initiatives increase customer loyalty and retention.

By focusing on these foundational elements, businesses can create a positive shopping experience that compels customers to return, fostering loyalty and driving long-term success. Once you have this in order, you can start looking into different customer retention strategies to boost your retention rate.

5 Powerful Sustainable Ecommerce Customer Retention Strategies

Customer retention is a bit like dating: you need to provide compelling reasons for the person to stick around. And these customer retention strategies are no different. At the core of each of these retention strategies is a compelling reason for existing customers to stick around, whether it’s store credit or emotional bonding.

Let’s go through the most effective ecommerce customer retention strategies that you’ll want to try on for your business.

1. Switch To Sustainable Packaging

sustainable packaging materials

According to our 2024 survey, 58% of all consumers are influenced by how products are packaged, with the number rising to 75% among younger shoppers. This preference for sustainable packaging options is a significant driver of loyalty; the survey also highlights that 71% of consumers feel good about purchasing sustainable products online, enhancing their likelihood to repeat purchase.

Here are a few easy and effective sustainable packaging strategies:

  • Choose recyclable or biodegradable materials.
  • Minimize packaging size and waste.
  • Educate about disposal and benefits.
  • Design for reuse or repurposing.
  • Promote sustainability visibly in branding.

2. Launch A Green Loyalty Program

The most popular (and proven) customer retention strategy in ecommerce is loyalty program marketing. Loyalty programs are a dynamic tool for enhancing customer retention and increasing purchase frequency. By introducing a points system, where customers earn points with every dollar spent—redeemable for discounts, products, or unique experiences—you create a compelling reason for customers to return. 

Incorporating sustainability into your loyalty programs can elevate these benefits further. Brands focused on sustainability see a 4% higher annual repeat rate than those less committed to green practices. This highlights how powerful sustainability can be in boosting brand loyalty, perhaps even more so than a loyalty program alone!

Consider rewarding customers who make sustainable choices, such as offsetting their carbon footprint with each order or purchasing eco-friendly products. 

Offer immediate benefits such as discounts or special access to new eco-friendly products to incentivize sustainable buying behavior. Customers appreciate loyalty programs that provide instant rewards, which positively influences their purchasing decisions. Ecommerce typically works well with discounts and dollar-based rewards, such as 10% off or $10 off next purchase.

Setting up a green loyalty program doesn’t have to be costly or complicated. There are quite a few reputable loyalty program software companies that can integrate seamlessly into your existing system. The investment can vary, but the ROI tends to be favorable as these programs are proven to increase customer lifetime value and repeat purchases.

You can expect to see increased customer engagement and retention relatively quickly after implementing a program, typically within a few months. Customers appreciate feeling valued, and a points system that rewards them for each purchase can significantly enhance their loyalty.

3. Offer Carbon Offsetting

Integrating EcoCart’s carbon offsetting widget at your checkout is a simple and effective way to showcase your commitment to sustainability. This feature enables customers to voluntarily offset the carbon footprint of their purchases, supporting environmental projects. Clearly communicate these impacts through your marketing channels and website to enhance their appeal.

The implementation is straightforward and can be easily integrated with most ecommerce platforms. The cost is minimal, especially considering the potential boost in customer loyalty and brand differentiation it provides.

Face the Future is a notable example of benefitting from connecting sustainability with customer loyalty. Loyalty program members who opted to use their points for climate-positive actions showed a 130% higher average order value and tripled their spending compared to non-members over a year. They also experienced a 200% increase in the number of purchases per loyalty customer. This data underscores the powerful link between sustainable practices and customer retention, demonstrating that customers engaged in sustainability efforts exhibit greater long-term value and loyalty.

Key Takeaway: Leverage EcoCart’s carbon offsetting to engage with environmentally conscious customers, reinforcing your dedication to sustainability and enhancing customer retention through shared values. This approach not only appeals to a growing demographic of eco-aware shoppers but also boosts your brand’s competitive edge.

4. Educate Through Email Marketing

Email marketing drives an impressive average return of $42 for every $1 spent, highlighting its potential for high ROI and customer engagement. To further boost the effectiveness of your email marketing in retaining customers, incorporating sustainability into your strategy can significantly multiply its impact. 

If you haven’t already, then invest in quality email marketing software that can handle segmentation, automation, and analytics. This allows you to measure the effectiveness of your campaigns and refine them over time. The cost can vary, but the returns in customer engagement and increased sales often justify the investment.

Here’s how you can seamlessly weave eco-conscious elements into your emails to engage and resonate deeply with your customers’ values:

  • Segment for sustainability: With a 14.31% higher open rate for segmented campaigns, it makes sense to further segment your email lists to target customers interested in sustainability. Highlight your environmental efforts like sustainable packaging or carbon offset projects, leveraging the strong emotional connection—93% among consumers aged 26-35—that such initiatives foster.
  • Personalize with purpose: Including the customer’s name and specific interests related to sustainability can boost open rates by 26%. Personalized content resonates more, enhancing engagement and fostering loyalty.
  • Be transparent in your sustainability journey: Educating your customers can make a significant difference on purchasing behavior and retention. Nearly 60% of email recipients say that marketing emails influence their purchasing decisions and 64% of consumers say that transparency in sustainability is their top priority when making purchasing decisions. Use this opportunity to educate customers about the impact of their purchases and share insights on your sustainability initiatives. 
  • Celebrate sustainability milestones: 61% of consumers prefer brands who prominently display their sustainability milestones on their website, but what if they haven’t been to your website in a while? Then display those achievements in your email marketing. Use automated emails to celebrate your brand’s sustainability achievements—like milestones in reducing carbon footprints or launching new eco-friendly products. 
  • Include visuals and video: Not only do emails including video content increase click rates by 200-300%, but they can also reduce your unsubscribe rate by 75%. Incorporate videos or infographics that showcase your sustainability efforts or explain the benefits of eco-friendly products to keep your customers interested and engaged.

Email marketing is a tried and true method for increasing engagement, revenue, and retention. By integrating sustainability into your established email marketing strategy, you capitalize on its known benefits while significantly enhancing your brand’s perceived value. This alignment with consumer demand for eco-friendly practices not only meets expectations but also elevates your brand, driving customer retention and revenue to new heights.

5. Amplify Retention With A Referral Program

Referral programs tap into the strength of your loyal customers to attract new customers, effectively reducing your customer acquisition costs while increasing lifetime value. In fact, referred customers boast a 37% higher retention rate compared to non-referred ones. To capitalize on this potent trend, offer your existing customers something they’re excited to share with their friends and family.

Companies that embrace green practices often exceed customer expectations, leading to higher satisfaction and loyalty. Satisfied customers are more likely to share positive word-of-mouth recommendations, boosting the brand’s reputation and appeal by aligning with their environmental values. Our customer example from earlier, Face the Future, is a good example of what an effective automated referral program capitalizing on green initiatives looks like:

Set up a system where both the referrer and the referee receive a reward, such as a discount or a free product, once the referred purchase is made. Facilitate the sharing process with simple one-click buttons for social media or email that are easily accessible from the customer’s account dashboard.

There are lots of established referral program software companies that can streamline this process for, with many options available that integrate directly into ecommerce systems. The setup cost varies, but the potential for rapid customer base expansion provides a strong return on investment.

Results from effective referral programs often include increased sales and a broader customer base, as people tend to trust recommendations from friends or family more than traditional advertising.

Ready To Increase Your Customer Retention With EcoCart?

As more consumers prioritize sustainability, businesses embracing eco-friendly practices are seeing significant gains in customer loyalty and retention. Integrating EcoCart’s carbon offsetting solutions can be a strategic move towards enhancing your brand’s appeal and commitment to environmental responsibility.

Ready to make sustainability a cornerstone of your customer retention strategy? Connect with EcoCart today to explore how sustainable solutions can benefit your business and help foster deeper customer connections.

dot mobile


Customer Examples

Young Mountain Tea

Case Studies

KAIBAE Delivers Lost Crops™ to Customers (Without the Carbon Footprint)

sustainable ecommerce

Your Roadmap to Sustainable Ecommerce

Discover sustainable ecommerce strategies to reduce environmental impact and meet the growing consumer demand for eco-friendly shopping practices.

Customer Examples

Young Mountain Tea

Case Studies

KAIBAE Delivers Lost Crops™ to Customers (Without the Carbon Footprint)

sustainable ecommerce

Your Roadmap to Sustainable Ecommerce

Discover sustainable ecommerce strategies to reduce environmental impact and meet the growing consumer demand for eco-friendly shopping practices.